Can I make this cake ahead of time without it getting soggy?

Absolutely. One of the things that makes this dessert so party-perfect is its durability. You can make the cake up to two days in advance , and it will still hold up beautifully in the fridge. To prevent sogginess: Don’t over-pour the gelatin. Stick to 1 cup boiling water + ½ cup cold juice or water. Let the cake cool slightly before adding the gelatin to ensure even absorption. Frost the cake just a few hours before serving to keep the topping fresh and fluffy. It’s these tips that make this recipe a stand-out compared to many other fruit-based desserts or creamy cakes that lose structure over time.

What’s the difference between the pudding and condensed milk versions?

Both styles are popular, and the choice depends on the texture you’re going for. The pudding version (as in the original Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake Recipe ) is lighter and fluffier, thanks to a blend of vanilla pudding and whipped topping. It’s easier to slice and has a mousse-like mouthfeel. The condensed milk version , seen in many “ Best Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake Recipes ” online, is richer and more indulgent. The milk adds sweetness and creates a denser, tres leches-style finish. Some readers love to combine the two for a next-level variation—pouring condensed milk over the gelatin-soaked cake, then finishing with the pudding topping. It’s a bold but delicious move.

Can I substitute mandarin orange juice for cold water in the gelatin mix?

Yes, you absolutely can—and it's a flavorful upgrade. Instead of using the standard ½ cup of cold water to mix with your orange Jell-O, try using mandarin orange juice straight from the can (after draining the oranges for topping). The juice infuses more authentic citrus notes and gives the cake a richer, fruitier taste. It’s a great way to amplify the creamsicle vibe and add depth to the gelatin layer. Some bakers also experiment with orange soda for a fizzy twist, which we covered earlier in our take on the orange creamsicle cake recipe with orange soda . Just be sure the liquid is cold before you mix it into the gelatin—it helps set the structure properly.

Is this the same as the 3 ingredient orange creamsicle cake?

Not quite. The 3 ingredient orange creamsicle cake is a simplified, shortcut version that uses just white cake mix, orange soda, and whipped topping—no gelatin, pudding, or fruit needed. It's great when you're low on time but still want that orange-vanilla flavor combo. However, the full Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake Recipe (like the one in this guide) delivers far more texture, moisture, and complexity, especially with the Jell-O layer and creamy topping. Think of it as the full-flavor, upgraded version.

Can I turn this into cupcakes or layered trifle desserts?

Definitely! This Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake Recipe is super versatile. For cupcakes, divide the batter evenly into cupcake tins, bake, poke, and drizzle with gelatin as usual. Top each with a swirl of pudding-cream frosting and a mandarin slice. If you're going for a showstopper, layer cubes of the cake into a trifle dish. Alternate with whipped topping and mandarin oranges to create a visual and flavorful masterpiece. Both options are great for feeding a crowd and creating beautiful presentation moments.

Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake Recipe – The Best Summer Treat

Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake Recipe: Unbelievably Easy & Delicious Treat

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star No reviews

Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: 30 minutes
Total Time: 3 hours 50 minutes (including chilling)
Yield: 12 servings 1x
Category: Dessert
Method: Baking
Cuisine: American
Diet: Vegetarian

Description

This refreshing Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake combines citrusy orange Jell-O, creamy vanilla pudding, and fluffy whipped topping over a soft white cake base—perfect for spring gatherings, summer potlucks, or anytime you crave a nostalgic treat!

Ingredients

Units Scale

14.25 ounces white cake mix (1 box), plus ingredients listed on box (usually eggs, oil, and water)
3 ounces orange Jell-O
1 cup boiling water
1/2 cup cold water
3.4 ounces instant vanilla pudding mix (1 box)
1 cup milk
8 ounces whipped topping, thawed
11 ounces mandarin oranges, drained (1 can)
Fresh mint sprigs for garnish, optional

Cook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark

Instructions

Preheat the oven according to the directions on the white cake mix box.
Coat a 9×13-inch baking pan with cooking spray.
Prepare and bake the cake according to package directions.
Let the cake cool for 15 minutes, then poke holes all over the top using a fork.
In a medium bowl, whisk the orange Jell-O with the boiling water until completely dissolved. Stir in the cold water.
Pour the Jell-O mixture evenly over the cake. Cover and refrigerate for at least 3 hours or up to 2 days.
In a large bowl, mix the milk and vanilla pudding mix until smooth and thickened.
Fold in the whipped topping until well combined.
Spread the whipped topping mixture over the chilled cake.
Top with mandarin oranges and garnish with mint sprigs if desired.
Slice into squares and serve.

Notes

For best results, use cold milk when mixing the pudding.
Letting the cake chill overnight helps the flavors meld beautifully.
You can substitute sugar-free Jell-O or pudding for a lighter version.

Nutrition

Serving Size: 1 slice
Calories: 280
Sugar: 28g
Sodium: 310mg
Fat: 9g
Saturated Fat: 4g
Unsaturated Fat: 4g
Trans Fat: 0g
Carbohydrates: 44g
Fiber: 0g
Protein: 3g
Cholesterol: 20mg

Find it online: https://www.cookingflash.com/orange-creamsicle-poke-cake-recipe/

\r\n <\/div>\r\n<\/div>\r\n","isUserRated":"0","version":"7.6.31","wc_post_id":"20957","isCookiesEnabled":"1","loadLastCommentId":"0","dataFilterCallbacks":[],"phraseFilters":[],"scrollSize":"32","url":"https:\/\/www.cookingflash.com\/wp-admin\/admin-ajax.php","customAjaxUrl":"https:\/\/www.cookingflash.com\/wp-content\/plugins\/wpdiscuz\/utils\/ajax\/wpdiscuz-ajax.php","bubbleUpdateUrl":"https:\/\/www.cookingflash.com\/wp-json\/wpdiscuz\/v1\/update","restNonce":"5993f44c3a","is_rate_editable":"0","menu_icon":"https:\/\/www.cookingflash.com\/wp-content\/plugins\/wpdiscuz\/assets\/img\/plugin-icon\/wpdiscuz-svg.svg","menu_icon_hover":"https:\/\/www.cookingflash.com\/wp-content\/plugins\/wpdiscuz\/assets\/img\/plugin-icon\/wpdiscuz-svg_hover.svg","is_email_field_required":"1"};