Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman): The Ultimate Comfort You Need Now

Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) is the ultimate comfort food, blending the savory flavors of a classic cheeseburger into a sliceable, satisfying pie. This dish takes everything we love about the American cheeseburger and layers it into a hearty pie form—cheesy, beefy, and rich with flavor. Inspired by the rustic simplicity of Pioneer Woman recipes, this version is packed with personality, homemade touches, and a nostalgic nod to classic family meals. Whether you’re a fan of old-fashioned cheeseburger pie or craving a modern twist, this recipe hits the spot.

This recipe was born from our About Page story, where CookingFlash started as a humble kitchen journal. One late evening, after running out of burger buns and trying to recreate the essence of a cheeseburger with pantry staples, our founder combined cooked beef, cheddar, and a homemade buttermilk batter. That improvised bake sparked an obsession—and this blog. Today’s cheeseburger pie recipe is the refined version of that late-night experiment, now one of our most beloved dishes.

Learn more about creative comfort meals like our ultimate double cheeseburger pizza stack.

Now, let’s dive into everything you need to know about making the best cheeseburger pie recipe at home.

What Is Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)?

The Origin and Rise of Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

Cheeseburger pie, especially the Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman), is a layered dish that mimics the structure of a traditional cheeseburger—without the bun. It’s not just meat and cheese—it’s nostalgia baked into a flaky or crustless pie.

Old-fashioned cheeseburger pie recipes typically include ground beef, onions, cheddar cheese, and a baking mix like Bisquick or a homemade batter. The Pioneer Woman’s twist adds a little flair with buttermilk and Worcestershire for extra depth.

This crowd-pleasing comfort food gained momentum in the 1970s, making appearances in Betty Crocker booklets and later evolving into internet-famous versions—like this one.

Key Characteristics That Make It Special

• Meat-forward base: Lean ground beef cooked with onions
• Savory custard topping: Made from buttermilk, eggs, and flour
• Melty cheddar cheese finish: A gooey topping that browns beautifully
• Flexible add-ons: Think ketchup, pickles, and burger sauce

This dish has inspired hundreds of variations online, like cheeseburger pie with pie crust or cheeseburger pie without Bisquick. What makes this recipe stand out is its homemade batter—a fluffier, fresher alternative to store-bought baking mixes.

People Also Search For Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

Phrases like “Pioneer Woman cheeseburger pie” and “cheeseburger pie inspired by Pioneer Woman people also ask ingredients” show how popular and versatile this dish has become. Whether it’s crusted, crustless, or loaded with toppings, cheeseburger pie offers something for every appetite.

Print

Essential Ingredients You Need for Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

Classic Ingredients Inspired by Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

Making a standout Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)starts with basic ingredients—but the magic is in the details. Here’s what you’ll need to create that hearty, beefy, cheesy bite that feels like home:

Ingredient	Purpose	Tips/Substitutions
1 Tbsp. olive oil	For browning the meat	Can use canola or avocado oil
1 lb. lean ground beef	The star of the pie	Ground turkey or chicken for a lighter version
½ cup chopped yellow onion	Adds savory depth	Red onion or shallots can be used
½ tsp. kosher salt	Enhances flavor	Adjust to taste or use sea salt
1 Tbsp. Worcestershire sauce	Umami boost	Soy sauce in a pinch
Nonstick cooking spray	Prevents sticking in the pie plate	Butter works too
2 large eggs	Sets the filling	Can use egg substitute if needed
1 cup buttermilk (room temp)	Adds tang and moisture	See below for buttermilk alternatives
1 Tbsp. melted salted butter	Adds richness to the batter	Unsalted butter with a pinch of salt
½ cup all-purpose flour	Forms the pie’s base batter	Use gluten-free flour for dietary needs
1 tsp. baking powder	Helps the batter rise	Don’t skip—key to the texture
1 cup shredded cheddar cheese	Golden cheesy topping	Try Colby Jack or Monterey Jack
Pickle slices (optional)	Burger feel and tang	Bread & butter pickles or dill
Ketchup and burger sauce	For dipping or drizzling	Adds the signature burger twist

What Can You Use Instead of Buttermilk?

No buttermilk in the fridge? No problem. Here are two reliable homemade swaps:

• Milk + Vinegar or Lemon Juice: Mix 1 cup milk with 1 Tbsp. white vinegar or lemon juice. Let sit for 10 minutes.
• Greek Yogurt + Milk: Mix ¾ cup yogurt with ¼ cup milk for a thicker, tangy result.

These substitutions work perfectly in this cheeseburger pie recipe, helping maintain the moisture and slight tang buttermilk brings.

Can You Make Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) with Bisquick?

Absolutely—you can swap the homemade batter for a quick Bisquick version. Combine Bisquick mix, eggs, and milk to form a pourable batter. However, the homemade version in this Pioneer Woman-inspired pie offers a richer, fluffier texture.

Still craving convenience? Try our twist on fast and fun cheeseburger flavors in this cheeseburger tater tot nachos recipe.

Why Every Ingredient Matters

Each element in this pie plays a crucial role—from the Worcestershire-spiked beef to the tang of the buttermilk. That balance is what elevates this from a basic bake to the best Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) you’ll make all year.

How to Make Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) Step-by-Step

Start with Oven and Prep Work for Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

The first step to perfect cheeseburger pie (inspired by Pioneer Woman) is getting your oven hot and ready. Preheat it to 400°F. This ensures the batter cooks evenly, the cheese gets bubbly, and the entire pie firms up without drying out.

Next, grab a 9-inch pie plate and coat it with nonstick cooking spray or a touch of butter. A greased dish is key to lifting out clean, golden slices—no sticking, no mess.

Cook the Burger Filling for Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

In a large skillet, warm 1 tablespoon of olive oil over medium heat. Add:

• 1 pound lean ground beef
• ½ cup chopped yellow onion
• ½ teaspoon kosher salt

Cook this mixture for 8 to 10 minutes, stirring occasionally. You’ll know it’s ready when the beef is fully browned and the onions are soft and translucent.

Now, stir in 1 tablespoon of Worcestershire sauce and cook for another 2 minutes. This adds deep umami flavor that sets this old-fashioned cheeseburger pie apart. Once combined, remove from heat and pour the mixture into your prepared pie plate.

Check out this breakfast grilled cheese with eggs if you love savory skillet meals.

Make the Buttermilk Batter for Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

In a mixing bowl, whisk together:

• 2 large eggs
• 1 cup buttermilk (room temperature)
• 1 tablespoon melted salted butter

Once combined, add:

• ½ cup all-purpose flour
• 1 teaspoon baking powder

Whisk again until you have a smooth, pourable batter. This homemade base is what makes this recipe more flavorful than a typical cheeseburger pie with Bisquick. It’s fluffier, fresher, and incredibly easy to whip up.

Build the Pie for Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

Pour your batter over the meat and onion mixture. Gently tilt the pie plate or use a spatula to distribute it evenly.

Then sprinkle the top with 1 cup of shredded cheddar cheese. This layer melts down during baking to form a cheesy, golden topping that pulls everything together.

Slide the pie into the oven and bake for 25 minutes, or until the center sets and the top turns golden and slightly crisp. You’ll know it’s ready when a toothpick inserted into the middle comes out clean.

Serve with Your Favorite Burger Sides

Allow the pie to cool for about 5–10 minutes before cutting. This rest time helps it set, making slicing easy and clean.

Serve warm, garnished with:

• Pickle slices
• Ketchup drizzles
• Homemade burger sauce (we’ll break that down in Part 5)

This dish brings the satisfaction of a classic burger into every cheesy, beefy bite. No buns needed—just real, hearty comfort food.

Don’t miss our cheeseburger mini sliders if you’re looking to serve crowd-pleasing party bites next.

Whether it’s your first time making it or you’re testing out a twist, this cheeseburger pie inspired by Pioneer Woman is guaranteed to earn a spot in your regular dinner rotation.

Flavorful Toppings and Creative Ways to Customize Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

Transform Your Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) with Toppings

A big part of what makes this Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) so memorable is how customizable it is. Just like building your favorite burger, you can take this pie in any direction with toppings that elevate each slice into something even more crave-worthy.

Here are some tried-and-true favorites:

• Pickles – Add a few tangy slices on top before serving for that true burger feel.
• Fresh tomatoes – Juicy tomato slices bring freshness and contrast.
• Shredded lettuce – Toss it on right before serving for a “burger-in-a-bowl” twist.
• Red onion rings – For extra bite, add thin slices raw or lightly pickled.
• Bacon bits – Crumbled crispy bacon turns it into a bacon cheeseburger pie.
• Avocado – Creamy and rich, especially when paired with spicy elements.
• Sriracha or hot sauce – Drizzle on top for a kick of heat.
• Cheeseburger sauce – Adds a creamy, tangy element that ties it all together.

Feel free to experiment. Like the Pioneer Woman herself, this dish welcomes a bit of flair.

Check out our take on cheesy garlic butter mushroom-stuffed chicken for more inventive comfort food ideas.

Should You Add a Crust?

Traditional versions of this Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) recipe are made crustless, which keeps things simple and low-carb. But if you’re craving that buttery, flaky base, go for it.

Here are three fun crust alternatives:

• Classic pie crust – Store-bought or homemade, this adds a flaky bite under the beef.
• Hash brown crust – Crispy and golden, this one’s a brunch lover’s dream.
• Puff pastry – Want that bakery-style golden top? Puff pastry gives elegance without effort.

If you’ve only made Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) without Bisquick, this homemade batter + crust combo is the upgrade you didn’t know you needed.

Meat Swaps and Substitutions

Beef is traditional—but this Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) handles meat variations like a champ. Whether you’re adapting to dietary needs or just want a change, try one of these:

Alternative Meat	What It Brings	Tips
Ground turkey	Light and mild	Boost flavor with extra onion or garlic
Ground chicken	Lean, subtle flavor	Season well and pair with bold toppings
Ground pork	Rich and savory	Great with BBQ-style sauces
Vegan meat crumbles	Plant-based and filling	Keep cheese and toppings dairy-free
Leftover roast beef	Deep, slow-cooked flavor	Chop finely before layering

From old-fashioned Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) lovers to plant-based foodies, everyone can make this dish their own.

Looking for more twists? Try this creamy garlic crab-stuffed mushrooms for another creative variation on a comforting classic.

Add-Ins to Boost Flavor

Want to take it even further? Toss in some extras to make your pie even more exciting:

• Diced jalapeños – For a spicy punch
• Cooked mushrooms – Earthy, meaty, and flavorful
• Roasted red peppers – Adds sweetness and a pop of color
• Corn or black beans – For a Tex-Mex twist
• Sun-dried tomatoes – For intense, tangy flavor
• Crumbled tortilla chips – For crunch and contrast

These extras work well whether you’re sticking to a classic version or turning your pie into a cheeseburger taco mashup.

Whip Up the Perfect Burger Sauce & Serve Cheeseburger Pie Like a Pro

The Ultimate Homemade Burger Sauce

One thing that sets this Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)apart from your average weeknight dinner? The sauce. A creamy, tangy burger sauce adds the perfect finishing touch, taking your pie from tasty to unforgettable.

You don’t need to buy anything fancy—this quick DIY version delivers all the classic burger shop flavors using simple pantry staples.

Quick Burger Sauce Recipe for Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

You’ll need:

• ½ cup mayonnaise
• 2 tablespoons ketchup
• 1 tablespoon yellow mustard
• 1 tablespoon sweet pickle relish
• 1 teaspoon white vinegar
• ½ teaspoon garlic powder
• Optional: pinch of smoked paprika for extra depth

To make it:

1. Combine everything in a bowl.
2. Stir until the sauce is silky and fully blended.
3. Chill it for 10–15 minutes in the fridge to help the flavors settle.

Once ready, you can use this sauce to drizzle over slices, serve on the side as a dip, or even spread it on a slice of toasted bread to go full burger mode.

Looking for inspiration? Try this cheesy patty melts with special sauce for another sauce-forward meal idea.

Plating and Pairing Like a Pro

When your cheeseburger pie comes out of the oven, give it a few minutes to rest. This helps the custard-style batter finish setting, so each slice stays neat and flavorful.

Here’s how to serve it up like a kitchen boss:

• Slice with confidence: Use a sharp knife or pie server to cut clean wedges.
• Top it off: Add a spoonful of burger sauce, a few pickle rounds, or even a sprinkle of chopped onions.
• Add a fresh or crispy side:
  • Sweet potato fries
  • Oven-roasted veggies
  • Crisp romaine salad with ranch
  • Garlic breadsticks

Whether you’re going casual or classy, these pairings turn a humble Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) recipe into a well-rounded meal everyone wants seconds of.

Don’t miss our crispy golden chicken with creamy Parmesan mushroom sauce for another dinnertime showstopper.

Crowd-Pleaser, Leftover Hero

This isn’t just a meal—it’s meal prep magic. After the first night, your Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) makes the perfect second-day lunch or dinner. Just wrap individual slices tightly and reheat when ready.

How to Store and Reheat Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) the Right Way

Store It Like a Pro

After baking your Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman), you’ll probably have leftovers—especially if you’re feeding a small family. The good news? It stores incredibly well and keeps all its flavor for days.

Here’s how to keep it fresh:

• Cool Completely: Let the pie cool to room temperature before storing. This helps avoid sogginess and keeps condensation out of your container.
• Use an Airtight Container: Store slices in an airtight container or wrap tightly with plastic wrap and aluminum foil.
• Refrigerator: It will stay fresh for up to 4 days in the fridge.
• Label It: Add a label with the date to make sure it doesn’t get lost in the fridge shuffle.

Learn more about simple storage tips with our no-bake peanut butter oat cups—perfect for make-ahead snacks.

Can You Freeze Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)?

Yes! Freezing this dish works beautifully—making it perfect for batch cooking or meal prep.

Here’s how to freeze it properly:

1. Allow the pie to cool completely after baking.
2. Cut into individual slices for easier reheating.
3. Wrap each slice tightly in plastic wrap, then in foil to prevent freezer burn.
4. Place wrapped slices in a zip-top freezer bag or freezer-safe container.
5. Label with the date and freeze for up to 2 months.

When you’re ready to enjoy it again, just pull a slice from the freezer and follow the reheating tips below.

Check out our satisfying walking taco casserole if you’re into freezer-friendly comfort food.

Reheat Like It’s Fresh Out of the Oven forCheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

No one wants a soggy reheated pie. Follow these simple steps to keep it crisp on the outside and melty on the inside:

Option 1: Oven

Best for maintaining that golden cheese top and solid structure.

• Preheat oven to 350°F.
• Place the slice on a baking sheet.
• Cover loosely with foil and bake for 12–15 minutes.
• Remove foil in the last 2–3 minutes for a crispy finish.

Option 2: Toaster Oven

Perfect for reheating single slices quickly.

• Set toaster oven to 350°F.
• Heat for 10–12 minutes, uncovered.

Option 3: Microwave (Quick Fix)

Only use this when you’re in a rush—texture might soften.

• Place on a microwave-safe plate.
• Cover with a damp paper towel.
• Heat in 30-second bursts until hot.

Once hot, don’t forget the toppings! A drizzle of burger sauce, a few pickle slices, or even a bit of fresh lettuce can bring it all back to life.

Kid-Friendly, Budget-Smart & Family-Approved Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

Why Kids and Picky Eaters Love It

If you’ve ever faced the challenge of getting your kids to eat something other than chicken nuggets, this Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) might just become your new family hero. It tastes like a cheeseburger, looks like a slice of pizza, and sneaks in real ingredients without the fuss.

Here’s what makes it a kid-favorite:

• Mild, familiar flavors – Ground beef, cheddar, and eggs are simple, comforting ingredients kids already know and love.
• No weird textures – Everything is soft, cheesy, and easy to chew.
• It looks fun – Cut into triangle slices like pizza, and suddenly they’re all in.
• Easy to eat with fingers or fork – Great for toddlers or older kids alike.

Want to make it extra fun? Let them add their own toppings before serving. A little shredded lettuce or ketchup drizzle gives them control—and gets them excited to eat

Stretch Your Grocery Budget

One of the most underrated features of this Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) recipe is how budget-friendly it is. You don’t need pricey cuts of meat or exotic ingredients. Just pantry basics and smart swaps.

Ways to Cut Costs Without Losing Flavor:

• Use ground turkey instead of beef – Still flavorful, often cheaper
• Make your own buttermilk – Just milk + vinegar or lemon juice
• Buy block cheese and shred it yourself – More cheese, lower cost
• Freeze leftovers for another meal – One dish, two dinners
• Skip the crust – No need to buy pastry when the batter does it all

These swaps make it easier to feed your family well without overspending—and you still get that rich, satisfying cheeseburger flavor.

Busy Week? This Pie Has Your Back

Between work, school pickups, and errands, it can feel impossible to get a hot, homemade meal on the table. That’s where this recipe truly shines.

Why it’s made for busy families:

• Ready in under an hour
• Minimal prep – One pan, one bowl, one pie plate
• Great for meal prep – Bake once, eat twice
• Kid-approved and customizable
• Freezer-friendly for when life gets hectic

Want to save even more time? Cook the beef and onion mixture ahead of time and store it in the fridge. Then just whip up the batter and bake it fresh when you’re ready.

You can even prep the entire pie the night before, cover it, and refrigerate until it’s time to bake. Wake up, pop it in the oven, and breakfast-for-dinner is served.

Healthier Versions for Every Lifestyle

Lighten Up Without Losing Flavor

You don’t have to give up comfort food just because you’re eating lighter. This Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) can be adjusted to suit a variety of health goals, from reducing calories to balancing your macros.

Easy Ways to Make It Lighter:

• Swap the ground beef: Use lean ground turkey or ground chicken for less fat.
• Reduce the cheese: A little goes a long way—try ¾ cup instead of a full cup, or use reduced-fat cheddar.
• Cut the butter: Try using just half the amount, or replace with olive oil.
• Add veggies: Sneak in spinach, mushrooms, or zucchini for added nutrition without changing the flavor.

Even with these tweaks, you’ll still get a golden, hearty slice that feels indulgent but fits your wellness routine.

Gluten-Free? No Problem

This recipe is naturally easy to convert into a gluten-free version. There’s no crust needed, and just one minor adjustment in the batter can make it safe for those with gluten sensitivities.

Gluten-Free Tweaks:

• Use gluten-free flour: A 1:1 gluten-free blend works perfectly in place of all-purpose flour.
• Watch your Worcestershire sauce: Choose a certified gluten-free brand.
• Avoid Bisquick: If you’re used to Bisquick-style pies, go with the homemade batter—it’s safer and tastes fresher.

You’ll still get the classic cheesy texture and savory base you expect from a great cheeseburger pie recipe.

Going Low-Carb? This Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) Can Go There

Craving that cheeseburger goodness without the carbs? You’re in luck. With a few low-carb substitutions, you can transform this recipe into a keto-friendly option.

Low-Carb Suggestions:

• Replace flour with almond flour: About ¼ cup will do, keeping carbs low and texture light.
• Swap buttermilk for heavy cream + water: This keeps the batter rich without adding sugar.
• Add low-carb veggies: Try cauliflower rice, spinach, or mushrooms as add-ins.
• Use sugar-free ketchup or skip it entirely in favor of mustard or hot sauce.

This version of the Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) keeps all the meatiness and cheesy goodness—without the carb overload.

A Comfort Food Classic Worth Repeating

If you’re craving a meal that’s warm, hearty, family-approved, and endlessly adaptable, look no further than this Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman). It takes everything we love about the classic cheeseburger—juicy ground beef, melty cheese, and rich flavor—and transforms it into a satisfying slice you can serve any night of the week.

From weeknight dinners and freezer meal preps to potlucks and family gatherings, this recipe shines for its ease, flavor, and flexibility. Whether you’re making it gluten-free, low-carb, dairy-light, or topped with pickles and burger sauce, it’s the kind of dish that always hits the spot.

It’s no wonder people are constantly searching for Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman) recipes, crust variations, and Pioneer Woman-style comfort dishes—because once you’ve tried a bite, it’s hard not to come back for more.

So next time you want to serve something nostalgic, affordable, and crowd-pleasing, skip the drive-thru and bake up a pie that delivers real homemade magic. Tray this :Sloppy Joe Pie and enjoy Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)

Watch How to Make Cheeseburger Pie (Inspired by Pioneer Woman)